My landlord won't give back my security deposit

Answered by ProctorLaw

This is general legal information, not legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created. Talk with a licensed attorney about your situation.

Short answer: Ohio gives a landlord 30 days after the lease ends and you hand back possession to either return the deposit or send you a written, itemized list of deductions with whatever balance is left (R.C. 5321.16(B)). You are past 30 days with nothing, and you gave a written forwarding address, which is the one condition the statute puts on tenants. That means you can sue for the amount wrongfully withheld plus an equal amount as damages, so double, plus your attorney fees (R.C. 5321.16(C)). This is one of the most tenant-friendly provisions in Ohio law, and the Ohio Supreme Court has held it applies whether or not the landlord acted in bad faith.

What the landlord can and cannot deduct. Unpaid rent and the cost of repairing damage you caused beyond normal wear and tear are legitimate. Routine turnover costs (repainting the landlord does between every tenant, carpet cleaning after a normal tenancy, a flat "cleaning fee" with no itemization), damage you did not cause, and replacing a whole item when only part was damaged are not. Keep in mind that the double-damages penalty applies to the portion wrongfully withheld: if the landlord later proves $200 of legitimate damage, you recover the rest, doubled, not the whole deposit doubled. Also, if your deposit was more than one month's rent and you stayed at least six months, the excess earns 5 percent interest (R.C. 5321.16(A)).

Step one: a written demand. Send a dated letter by certified mail (and email, if that is how you communicated) to the address where you paid rent. State the move-out date, the date you returned the keys, your forwarding address again, the deposit amount, and that R.C. 5321.16 required an itemized statement within 30 days. Give a short deadline, ten days, and say you will file in small claims for double damages and fees if you do not hear back. Ohio Legal Help has a free letter generator for exactly this. A surprising number of deposits appear after this letter.

Step two: small claims. Franklin County Municipal Court's small claims division handles claims up to $6,000 (R.C. 1925.02), which comfortably covers a doubled deposit. File at the Clerk of Courts civil division, 375 S. High St., 3rd floor; the filing cost is currently $92 plus a few dollars for service, no lawyer required, and every case gets a hearing before a magistrate. Bring the lease, proof you paid the deposit, your move-out photos, the letter with the forwarding address, and your demand letter with the certified-mail receipt. Ask for the deposit, the statutory double damages, interest, and costs. If you do hire a lawyer, the fee-shifting provision means the landlord can be ordered to pay the fees, which is why some attorneys will take these cases.

Two cautions. First, deadlines: the limitations period for the double-damages claim is unsettled, and a landlord may argue the one-year statute for penalties applies, so file promptly. Second, if you owe anything, the landlord can counterclaim for unpaid rent or real damage and offset it, so be realistic about what the unit looked like when you left.

Columbus has added city-level renter protections in recent years (written receipts for every payment, installment deposits for landlords with five or more units, and a rental registry that takes effect in January 2027), but the deposit-return rule and the double-damages remedy come from the state statute and apply to every landlord in Ohio. This is general information, not legal advice; a tenant-rights attorney or the Legal Aid Society of Columbus can review your specific facts.

8.